Skip to content


The Digital Economy Bill: The Power of Not Being Elected

Gordon Brown, the UK PM, will be calling for a general election very soon; he may even become the first to make that call in the Commons.

This is happening at a time when trust in the parliamentary process is low, perhaps even at an all-time low; my perspective is clouded by reports about expenses and second homes and cash-for-questions, cash-for-honours, cash-for-lobbying, cash-to-protect-oil, cash-for-something-or-the-other.

Against this backdrop, it would seem prudent to surmise that one of the issues this election is likely to be fought on is that of trust.

Trust. I’ve always seen trust in the way I see beards. It takes a long time to grow a decent beard. And minutes to lose the beard. So it is with trust.

Which is why I find the behaviour of our elected officials bizarre in the extreme when it comes to the treatment and passage of the Digital Economy Bill. If you want to know more, read Cory Doctorow here.

Did I say “elected officials”?

My mistake. I shouldn’t have said “elected officials”. Because when it comes down to it, many of the players in the Digital Economy Bill are anything but elected officials. Let’s take a look at who’s pushing the Bill and some of the key people involved in the debate.

Lord Mandelson. Unelected. Appointed. Powerful friend of  the Powerful. Friends include Lucian Grainge (Universal) and David Geffen (Asylum, Warner, Dreamworks SKG). Lord Birt. Unelected. Appointed. On the Supervisory Board of EMI. Lord Triesman. Unelected. Appointed. Chairman of the FA.  Lord Clement Jones. Unelected. Appointed. On the board of a company that makes its money on intellectual property law, and publicly showing himself to be of the opinion that civil breaches are similar to criminal offences.

A bunch of unelected officials. With clear ties to vested interests in music, film and intellectual property rights.

I’m used to bias. We all have bias. I think it was Einstein who said that common sense is the collection of prejudices we build by the time we’re eighteen. We all have masks and anchors that frame what we think and say.

But this is not about bias alone. Because, besides being unelected officials, we need to look at the way the Bill is being bums-rushed through Parliament. With no time for a proper debate. With a complete disregard for all the debate that has taken place earlier, proper or not.

Major amendments being put through in the days before Easter, in the days before the calling of a general election. Major amendments that would give presidential powers to ministers with scant regard for law or for human rights. Major amendments that would not stand the close scrutiny and heated debate that would normally take place. Major amendments being relegated to the horse-trading of wash-up, at a time when many of our elected officials are too busy thinking of a precious break away from it all, at a time when many of our elected officials are preparing to fight to be re-elected.

So we have unelected officials. With clear and present bias. Driving a process that is as far removed from trust as it is from democracy. Hoping people won’t notice.

People are noticing. And people will notice. There are many people who will make sure that people will notice.

The Digital Economy Bill now represents a wonderful opportunity for would-be next-Parliament MPs. Show us why we should trust you. Show us that you will stand in the gap and uphold democratic rights and due process. And think before you alienate a good slice of your electorate.

I guess dinosaurs have to be allowed their ritual dances as they exit the evolutionary stage. And this Bill, flawed as it is, may still become law. Because of clever timing, apathy. And the Power Of Not Being Elected.

But there will be consequences. You cannot tax salt.

Posted in Digital Economy Bill, DRM and IPR, Films, Music, Stupidity.

Tagged with , .


8 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Kevin Tea says

    Given the wealth that Blair has amassed since leaving office – including share options in an Iraqi oil company which begs the question was regime change the real reason we want to war or was it to feather his nest – one wonders whether Mandelson and co will receive similar kickbacks from the music industry.

    I recall the outcry over Cash For Questions when the Tories were last in power and wonder if Labour has taken this a step further with Cash For Legislation. Certainly Labour has a dodgy record with some ill thought out laws. The fox hunting bill was nothing to do with animal welfare but a result of ill conceived class warfare and a substantial donation from the Political Animal Lobby.

    Am I alone in being amazed at the number of Lord This, Lady That and Sir T’other that have been introduced since Labour came to power -my social grandparents will be spinning in their grave.

    While you are right to be outraged at the progress of DeBill what else can we expect from a self-serving party that has complete contempt for the electorate and, like kids in a sweetshop, want to gorge on what they can before the party ends.

  2. Martin Budden says

    Mandelson is worse than unelected – we’ve got rid of him three times, yet he keeps coming back. I’ve always maintained that the minimum criterion for a democracy is the ability to non-violently get rid of those in power. Unfortunately our democracy is failing us in even this most minimal respect.

    Things you can do:

    a) Write to your MP and ask them to oppose sending the DEB through wash-up.
    Ask them to sign Early Day Motion 1223, “Digital Economy Bill [Lords] 30.03.2010″
    http://edmi.parliament.uk/EDMi/EDMDetails.aspx?EDMID=40883&SESSION=903
    ” Mitchell, Austin
    That this House believes that the Digital Economy Bill [Lords] is too important to be taken further in the last days of a dying Parliament; and considers that a bill with so many repercussions for consumers, civil liberties, freedom of information and access to the internet should be debated and properly scrutinised at length and in detail, with a full opportunity for public discussion and representation in a new Parliament after the general election and not rushed through in the few days that remain in this Parliament.”
    (two MPs have already signed this).

    b) Co-sign the Power2010 Letter asking the three main party leaders not to appoint anyone else to the Lords: http://www.power2010.org.uk/page/s/secondchamber?source=third1

    c) Donate to the “Stop the Digital Economy Bill” campaign: https://secure.38degrees.org.uk/page/contribute/DigitalEconomyBillAd

  3. DE says

    If just a fraction of the animus against the bill was directed into facing up to the problems that rights holders have (or imagine they have), it may not have got this far.

    The big dinosaur interest groups have got their way, because in answer to the question “how do enforce copyright in the future?” too many netizens answered “there is no spoon”.

  4. Paramendra Bhagat says

    I see all the basic ingredients of revolt in here.

Continuing the Discussion

  1. jobsworth at 04/01/10 12:40:07 | Exectweets linked to this post on April 1, 2010

    [...] @billt @suw @kevinmarks http://confusedofcalcutta.com/2010/04/01/the-digital-economy-bill-the-power-of-not-being-elected/ jobsworth – Thu 01 Apr 12:40 previous next billgates [...]

  2. jobsworth at 04/01/10 12:37:01 | Exectweets linked to this post on April 1, 2010

    [...] Power of Not Being Elected #DEBill http://confusedofcalcutta.com/2010/04/01/the-digital-economy-bill-the-power-of-not-being-elected/ jobsworth – Thu 01 Apr 12:37 previous next billgates [...]

  3. links for 2010-04-01 « Onlinejournalismtest's Blog linked to this post on April 1, 2010

    [...] The Digital Economy Bill: The Power of Not Being Elected – confused of calcutta RT @tom_watson: RT @jobsworth: http://bit.ly/ap1oNY #debill (tags: debill via:packrati.us) [...]

  4. Links 2/4/2010: Ubuntu Manual as Audio, Firefox Claims Over 40% in Europe | Techrights linked to this post on April 2, 2010

    [...] The Digital Economy Bill: The Power of Not Being Elected The Digital Economy Bill now represents a wonderful opportunity for would-be next-Parliament MPs. Show us why we should trust you. Show us that you will stand in the gap and uphold democratic rights and due process. And think before you alienate a good slice of your electorate. [...]



Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.