Between them they go for a referential/experiential split for what I termed linkers/thinkers, and, by inference, define the stinker by leaving him out of the equation altogether. Kottke extends the simile to compare the writer/editor relationship and the musician/DJ relationship.
I think there is a lot of value in what they say. The only bit missing for me, something I have to figure out a way of including, is the co-creation bit.
More than any of the other creator/coordinator pairs described (writer/editor, musician/DJ, experiential/referential), something that makes the blogger stand out is the act of co-creation.
And bloggers recognise that intrinsic difference, so much so that (at least from my experience) the thinker-blogger normally frees up his “content” from the get-go. Why? Because he does not see it as owned or as content.
I think this is important.